×

Mathematics, religion, and Marxism in the Soviet Union in the 1930s. (English) Zbl 1085.01017

Mathematicians and traditional pure mathematics in the U.S.S.R. came under attack in the 1930s from the platforms of religion and nationalism in an attempt to establish dialectical materialistic mathematics. These platforms came to light at the 16th Congress of the All-Union Communist Party in 1930. A leader of the attacks was the mathematically inclined Marxist/Stalinist ideologue Ernst Kolman (1892–1979), in whose writings randomness and probability (more amenable to philosophical discourse than other areas of mathematics) are recurring issues. The recently rediscovered booklet “Mathematics and Religion”, written in 1933 under the influence of Kolman by the mathematician and political activist Mikhail Kh. Orlov (1900–1936), encompasses the Bolshevik position on mathematics and religion. A nucleus of vilification in Orlov’s book for his religiously inclined pre-revolutionary writings is the mathematician Pavel Alekseevich Nekrasov (1853–1924), and by extension, the Moscow Mathematical Society, a focus of attack by Kolman and others. The outstanding mathematicians/probabilists of the time, Andrei N. Kolmogorov (1903-1987) and Sergei N. Bernstein (1880–1968), prominent opponents of the “reforms” of Kolman (in Moscow) and Orlov (in Ukraine), respectively, are featured in this study.

MSC:

01A60 History of mathematics in the 20th century
01A80 Sociology (and profession) of mathematics
PDFBibTeX XMLCite
Full Text: DOI

References:

[1] Bolshaia Sovietskaia Entsiklopediia [The Great Soviet Encyclopedia], Edited by O.Iu. Schmidt (1938), [First (?) ed., 1934.]\(^{18}\)
[2] Matematika v SSSR za Sorok Let [Mathematics in the USSR Over 40 years] 1917-1957, Tom 2, Bibliografiia (1959), Gos.-Izd. Fiz.-Mat. Lit: Gos.-Izd. Fiz.-Mat. Lit Moscow
[3] Science at the Cross Roads. Papers Presented to the International Congress of the History of Science and Technology, held in London from June 29th to July 3rd, 1931, by the Delegates of the U.S.S.R (1971), Frank Cass: Frank Cass London, [First ed., 1931.]
[4] Akademiia Nauk USSR [Academy of Science of the Ukrainian SSSR] (1982), Akad. Nauk USSR: Akad. Nauk USSR Kyiv
[5] Bilokin’, Serhiy, Masovyi teror iak zasib derzhavnoho upravilinnia v SRSR (1917-1941 rr.) [Mass Terror as a Means of Government in the USSR (1917-1941)] (1999), Dzhereloznavche Doslidzhennia: Dzhereloznavche Doslidzhennia Kyiv
[6] Bogoliubov, A. N., Sergei Natanovich Bernstein, Voprosy Istor. Estestvoznan. i Tekhn., 3, 56-65 (1991), [In Russian.]
[7] Bogoliubov, A. N.; Matvievskaia, G. P., Vsevolod Ivanovich Romanovsky, 1879-1954, (Nauchno-biograficheskaia Literatura (1997), Nauka: Nauka Moscow)
[8] Bogomolov, S. A., Evoliutsiia Geometricheskoi Misli [The Evolution of Geometrical Thought] (1928), Nachatki Znanii: Nachatki Znanii Leningrad
[9] Boiarsky, A. Ya; Starovsky, V. N.; Khotimsky, V. I.; Yastremsky, B. S., Teoriia Matematicheskoi Statistiki (1931), Gosudarstvennoe Sotsial’no-Ekonomicheskoe Izdatelstvo: Gosudarstvennoe Sotsial’no-Ekonomicheskoe Izdatelstvo Moscow/Leningrad
[10] Buckingham, Paul, Mathematics as a tool for economic and cultural development: the philosophical views of the leading mathematicians of the Moscow Mathematical Society, 1867-1905, Michigan Academician, 31, 33-44 (1999)
[11] Buniakovsky, Viktor Ya, Osnovaniia Matematicheskoi Teorii Veroiatnostei [Foundations of the Mathematical Theory of Probabilities] (1846), St. Petersburg
[12] Colman, E. [Kolman, E.], 1931. The present crisis in the mathematical sciences and general outline for their reconstruction. In: Science at the Crossroads. Frank Cass, London, pp. 215-229, 1971; Colman, E. [Kolman, E.], 1931. The present crisis in the mathematical sciences and general outline for their reconstruction. In: Science at the Crossroads. Frank Cass, London, pp. 215-229, 1971
[13] Conquest, Robert, The Harvest of Sorrow (1986), Oxford: Oxford New York
[14] Demidov, Sergei S.; Ford, Charles E., N.N. Luzin and the affair of the ‘National Fascist Center’, (Dauben, Joseph; Folkerts, Menso; Knobloch, Eberhard; Wussing, Hans, History of Mathematics: States of the Art (1996), Academic Press: Academic Press New York), 137-148 · Zbl 0856.01023
[15] Demidov, Sergei S.; Esakov, V. D., “The affair of N.N. Luzin” in the collective memory of the scientific community, (Demidov and Levshin [1999] (1999)), 9-50, [In Russian.]
[16] (Demidov, Sergei S.; Levshin, B. V., Delo Akademika Nikolaia Nikolaevicha Luzina [The Affair of Academician Nikolai Nikolaevich Luzin] (1999), R.Kh.G.I: R.Kh.G.I Sankt-Peterburg), 312 pp · Zbl 0952.01013
[17] Florensky, Pavel A., Mnimost’ v geometrii [The Imaginary in Geometry] (1922), Pomore: Pomore Moscow
[18] Florenskii, P.A. [Florensky, Pavel A.], 1975. Le colonne et le fondement de la vérité : essai d’une théodicée orthodoxe. Lausanne. [Translation by Constantin Andronikof.]; Florenskii, P.A. [Florensky, Pavel A.], 1975. Le colonne et le fondement de la vérité : essai d’une théodicée orthodoxe. Lausanne. [Translation by Constantin Andronikof.]
[19] Florensky, Pavel A., Stolp i Utverzhdenie Istini [The Pillar and Foundation of Truth] (1990), Pravda: Pravda Moscow
[20] Florensky, Pavel A., The Pillar and Ground of Truth: An Essay in Orthodox Theodicity in Twelve Letters (1997), Princeton Univ. Press: Princeton Univ. Press Princeton, NJ, [Translation: Boris Jakim.]
[21] Ford, Charles E., Dmitrii Egorov: Mathematics and religion in Moscow, Math. Intelligencer, 13, 24-30 (1991) · Zbl 0722.01027
[22] Ford, Charles E., Mathematics and Marxism, (Eberhard Knobloch, Jean Mawhin, Sergei S. Demidov (Eds.). Studies in History of Mathematics Dedicated to A.P. Youshkevich. Eberhard Knobloch, Jean Mawhin, Sergei S. Demidov (Eds.). Studies in History of Mathematics Dedicated to A.P. Youshkevich, Proceedings of the XX International Congress of History of Science, vol. XIII (2002), Brepols: Brepols Turnhout), 345-361 · Zbl 1064.01517
[23] Ford, Charles E., The great break in the Moscow mathematical front, Istoriko-Matematicheskie Issledovaniia, New Series, 3, Old Series 38, 74-92 (1999), [In Russian.] · Zbl 0980.01023
[24] Gelfond, A.; Shnirelman, L., [Review in Russian of Kolman [1936].], Uspekhi Matematicheskikh Nauk, 4, 334-336 (1938)
[25] Hald, Anders, A History of Mathematical Statistics from 1750 to 1930 (1998), Wiley: Wiley New York · Zbl 0979.01012
[26] Hruby, Peter, Fools and Heroes. The Changing Role of Communist Intellectuals in Czechoslovakia (1980), Pergamon Press: Pergamon Press London, \(^{19}\)
[27] Joravsky, David, Soviet Marxism and Natural Science. 1917-1932 (1961), Routledge & Kegan Paul: Routledge & Kegan Paul London
[28] Kaganovich, Lazar M., Doklad Tov. Kaganovicha [Presentation of comrade Kaganovich], (XVI S’ezd Vsesoiuznoi Kommunisticheskoi Partii(b). Stenograficheskii Otchet. 2-e sterotipnoe izdanie (1931), Ogiz: Ogiz Moscow)
[29] Khoruzhy, S.S., 1990. O filosofii sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo [On the philosophy of the priest Pavel Florensky]. In: Florensky [1990], pp. VI-XVI; Khoruzhy, S.S., 1990. O filosofii sviashchennika Pavla Florenskogo [On the philosophy of the priest Pavel Florensky]. In: Florensky [1990], pp. VI-XVI
[30] Kolman, E., K voprosu o sluchainosti [On the question of randomness], Pod Znamenem Marksizma, 6, 153-157 (1926)
[31] Kolman, E., Bozhestvennaia evoliutsiia geometricheskoi misli [The divine evolution of geometrical thought], Estestvoznaniia i Marksizm, 1, 157-159 (1929)
[32] (Kolman, E., Na Borbu za Materialisticheskuiu Dialektiku v Matematike [The Battle for Materialist Dialectics in Mathematics] (1931), Gos. Nauch. Tekhn. Izdat: Gos. Nauch. Tekhn. Izdat Moscow)
[33] Kolman, E., Against the latest revelations of bourgeois obscurantism, Bolshevik, 12, 88-96 (1933), [In Russian.]
[34] Kolman, E., On the current meaning of the theory of probability, Pod Znamenem Marksizma, 2, 71-76 (1934), [In Russian.]
[35] Kolman, E., Predmet i Metod Sovremennoi Matematiki [The Subject Matter and Methodology of Current Mathematics] (1936), Sotsekgiz: Sotsekgiz Moscow
[36] Kolman, E., Is it possible to prove or disprove Mendelianism by mathematical and statistical methods?, C. R. (Dokl.) Acad. Sci. l’URSS, 28, 834-838 (1940)
[37] Kolman, Ernest, Bernard Bolzano (1955), Izd. AN SSSR: Izd. AN SSSR Moscow
[38] Kolman, Ernest, Istoriia Matematiki v Drevnosti [History of Mathematics in Antiquity] (1961), Gos.-Izd. Fiz.-Mat. Lit: Gos.-Izd. Fiz.-Mat. Lit Moscow, \(^{20}\)
[39] Kolman, Arnošt [Ernest], 1965. Considerations About the Certainty of Knowledge. Edited, and with an Introduction by Robert S. Cohen and Dirk J. Struik. In: Occasional Papers: No. 2. American Institute for Marxist Studies, New York; Kolman, Arnošt [Ernest], 1965. Considerations About the Certainty of Knowledge. Edited, and with an Introduction by Robert S. Cohen and Dirk J. Struik. In: Occasional Papers: No. 2. American Institute for Marxist Studies, New York
[40] Kolman, Arnošt, A. Kolman an Heinz Brandt, Europaische Ideen, 31/32, 19-20 (1977), \(^{21}\)
[41] Kolman, Arnošt, Die verirrte Generation. So hätten wir nicht leben sollen. Eine Biographie (1979), S. Fischer: S. Fischer Frankfurt-am-Main, [Vorbemerkungen: František Janouch, Stockholm, 7 March 1979.]\(^{22}\)
[42] Kolman, Arnošt, Gelehrter und Freiheitskämpfer, Europaischen Ideen, 48, 6-8 (1980), \(^{23}\)
[43] Kolman, Arnošt, Die verirrte Generation. So hätten wir nicht leben sollen. Eine Autobiographie. Ergänzt durch: Wie habt ihr so leben können? Ein Dialog zwischen František Janouch und Arnošt Kolman. Herausgegeben von Hanswilhelm Haefs und František Janouch (1982), Fischer Taschenbuch: Fischer Taschenbuch Frankfurt-am-Main, [Vorbemerkungen: František Janouch, Björknas, 26 Mai 1981. Nachwort des deutschen Herausgebers: Hanswilhelm Haefs, Bad Godesberg, 25 Juli 1981.]
[44] Kolman, Arnosht (Ernest), 1982b. My ne dolzhni byli tak zhit’ [We should not have lived that way]. Chalidze, New York. [Ob avtore (Preface: About the author) by František Janouch, Stockholm, 11 April 1982.]\(^{24}\); Kolman, Arnosht (Ernest), 1982b. My ne dolzhni byli tak zhit’ [We should not have lived that way]. Chalidze, New York. [Ob avtore (Preface: About the author) by František Janouch, Stockholm, 11 April 1982.]\(^{24}\)
[45] Kolman, E., Khotimsky, V.I., Ianovskaia, S.A. (Eds.), 1931. Matematicheskie Nauki Proletarskim Kadram. Sbornik po Voprosam Elementarnoi i Vysshei Matematiki [Mathematical Sciences for Proletarian Cadres. Symposium for Questions of Elementary and Higher Mathematics]. 1; Kolman, E., Khotimsky, V.I., Ianovskaia, S.A. (Eds.), 1931. Matematicheskie Nauki Proletarskim Kadram. Sbornik po Voprosam Elementarnoi i Vysshei Matematiki [Mathematical Sciences for Proletarian Cadres. Symposium for Questions of Elementary and Higher Mathematics]. 1
[46] Kolmogoroff, A. N., Sulla determinazione empirica di una legge di distribuzione, Giornale Istituto Italiano di Attuari, 4, 83-91 (1933) · Zbl 0006.17402
[47] Kolmogoroff, A. N., On a new confirmation of Mendel’s laws, C. R. (Dokl.) Acad. Sci. l’URSS, 27, 37-41 (1940) · Zbl 0023.25301
[48] Kolmogorov, Andrei N., Grundbegriffe der Wahrsheinlichkeitsrechnung (1933), Springer-Verlag: Springer-Verlag Berlin
[49] Kovaly, Pavel, Rehumanization or Dehumanization? Philosophical Essays on Current Issues of Marxist Humanism in Arnost Kolman, Gyorgy Lukacs, Adam Schaff, Alexander Solzhenitsyn (1974), Branden Press: Branden Press Boston
[50] Liusternik, L. A., The early years of the Moscow Mathematical School, Russian Math. Surveys, 22, 2, 171-211 (1967), [Part 2 of this article, English translation.]
[51] Lorentz, George G., Mathematics and Politics in the Soviet Union from 1928 to 1953, J. Approx. Theory, 116, 169-223 (2002) · Zbl 1006.01009
[52] Losev, A. F., Antichnii kosmos v sovremennoi nauke [The Antique Cosmos in Contemporary Science] (1927), Published by the author: Published by the author Moscow
[53] Markoff, A. A., Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung (1912), Teubner: Teubner Tübingen, [German translation by Heinrich Liebmann of Markov [1908].] · JFM 43.0291.01
[54] Markov, Andrei A., 1908. Ischislenie Veroiatnostei [The Calculus of Probabilities], second ed; Markov, Andrei A., 1908. Ischislenie Veroiatnostei [The Calculus of Probabilities], second ed
[55] Markov, Andrei A., 1913. Ischislenie Veroiatnostei [The Calculus of Probabilities], third ed; Markov, Andrei A., 1913. Ischislenie Veroiatnostei [The Calculus of Probabilities], third ed
[56] Markov, Andrei A., Ischislenie Veroiatnostei [The Calculus of Probabilities] (1924), Gosizdat: Gosizdat Moscow
[57] Markov, Andrei A., Izbrannie Trudy [Selected Works] (1951), AN SSSR: AN SSSR Leningrad
[58] Nekrasov, Pavel A., Filosofiia i Logika Nauki o Massovikh Proiavleniiakh Chelovecheskoi Deiatelnosti. Peresmotr Osnovanii Sotsial’noi Fiziki Ketle [The Philosophy and Logic of the Science of Mass Phenomena in Human Activity. A Review of the Foundations of the Social Physics of Quetelet] (1902), Universitetskaia Tipografiia: Universitetskaia Tipografiia Moscow
[59] Nekrasov, Pavel A., Teoriia Veroiatnostei [Theory of Probabilities] (1912), K.L. Rikker: K.L. Rikker St. Petersburg, [An earlier version of the technical textbook part was published in 1896.]
[60] Nekrasov, Pavel A., Srednaia Shkola, Matematika i Nauchnaia Podgotovka Uchitelei (1916), Moscow, pp. 16, 17, 19
[61] (Ondar, Kh. O., The Correspondence Between A.A. Markov and A.A. Chuprov on the Theory of Probability and Mathematical Statistics (1981), Springer-Verlag: Springer-Verlag New York), [Translated by C. & M. Stein.] · Zbl 0476.62002
[62] Orlov, M., Borot’ba za markso-lenins’ku metodologiu v matematitsi [The fight for Marxist-Leninist ideology in mathematics (in Ukrainian)], Zh. Mat. Tsik’lu VseUkrainskoi Akad. Nauk, 1 (1931), \(^{25}\)
[63] Orlov, M., Inzhenerna Matematyka [Engineering Mathematics], Chastyna Persha [Part One] (1931), Ukrderzhtekhvydav: Ukrderzhtekhvydav Kharkiv/Kyiv
[64] Orlov, M., Inzhenerna Matematyka [Engineering Mathematics], Chastyna Druha [Part Two] (1932), Tekhnichne Vydavnytstvo: Tekhnichne Vydavnytstvo Kharkiv/Kyiv
[65] Orlov, M., Matematyka i Religiia [Mathematics and Religion] (1933), Proletar: Proletar Partvydav
[66] Papin, J., Florenskii, Pavel Aleksandrovich, (New Catholic Encyclopedia, vol. 5 (1967), McGraw-Hill: McGraw-Hill New York), 974
[67] Pearson, Karl, The Grammar of Science (1900), A. & C. Black: A. & C. Black London, \(^{26}\) · JFM 23.0048.02
[68] Porter, Theodore M., Reason, faith and alienation in the Victorian Fin-de-Siècle, (Bödecke, H. E.; Reill, P. H.; Schlumbohm, J., Wissenschaft als kulturelle Praxis (1999), Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht: Vandenhoeck and Ruprecht Göttingen), 401-413
[69] Quetelet, L. Adolphe J., Physique Sociale ou Essai sur le Developpement des Facultés de l’ Homme (1869), Muquardt: Muquardt Brussels
[70] Rozhenko, Mykola, Trahediia akademika Iurintsia [The Tragedy of Academician Iurinets (Jurinec)] (1996), Ukrains’kii Tsentr Dukhovnoi Kul’tury: Ukrains’kii Tsentr Dukhovnoi Kul’tury Kyiv
[71] Rozhenko, Mykola; Bohats’ka, E., Sosny Bykivni svidchat’: zlochyn proty liudstva [The Pines of Bykivnia Bear Witness: A Crime Against Humanity] (1996), Ukrains’kii Tsentr Dukhovnoi Kultury: Ukrains’kii Tsentr Dukhovnoi Kultury Kyiv, \(^{27}\)
[72] Seneta, Eugene, The central limit problem and linear least squares in pre-Revolutionary Russia. The background, Math. Sci., 9, 37-77 (1984) · Zbl 0542.01003
[73] Seneta, Eugene, A sketch of the history of survey sampling in Russia, J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. A, 148, 118-125 (1985) · Zbl 0606.62001
[74] Seneta, E., Krawtchouk polynomials and Australian statisticians, IMS. Bull., 22, 4, 421 (1993)
[75] Seneta, Eugene, Markov and the birth of chain dependence theory, Internat. Stat. Rev., 64, 255-263 (1996) · Zbl 0918.60008
[76] Seneta, Eugene, C.L. Dodgson (Lewis Carroll) 1832-1898, Stat. Soc. Australia Inc. Newslett., 83, 12-13 (1998)
[77] Seneta, Eugene, Early influences on probability and statistics in the Russian Empire, Arch. Hist. Exact Sci., 53, 201-213 (1998) · Zbl 0917.01019
[78] Seneta, Eugene, 2003. Statistical regularity and free will: L.A.J. Quetelet and P.A. Nekrasov. Internat. Stat. Rev., in press; Seneta, Eugene, 2003. Statistical regularity and free will: L.A.J. Quetelet and P.A. Nekrasov. Internat. Stat. Rev., in press · Zbl 1114.62302
[79] Sluginov, S. P., Nekrasov, P.A, Trudy Matem. Seminariia. Gosud. Universitet. Perm., 1, 37-38 (1927), [In Russian.] · JFM 53.0035.07
[80] Stigler, Stephen M., The History of Statistics (1986), Belknap: Belknap Cambridge, MA · Zbl 0656.62005
[81] Struik, Dirk J., On the foundations of the theory of probabilities, Philos. Sci., 1, 50-70 (1934)
[82] Struik, D. J., On the foundation of the theory of probability, Pod Znamenem Marksizma, 2, 77-96 (1934), [in Russian]
[83] Vucinich, Alexander, Mathematics and dialectics in the Soviet Union: The pre-Stalin period, Historia Math., 26, 107-124 (1999) · Zbl 0944.01006
[84] Vucinich, Alexander, Soviet mathematics and dialectics in the Stalin era, Historia Math., 27, 54-76 (2000) · Zbl 0947.01010
[85] Yastremsky, B. S., On the statistical analysis of the fulfilment of planning tasks in the light of the work of I.V. Stalin, (Economic Problems of Socialism in the USSR [in Russian] (1953), Ministerstvo Kulturi SSSR: Ministerstvo Kulturi SSSR Moscow)
[86] Yastremsky, B. S., The legend of the miraculous role of the law of large numbers, Vestnik Statistiki, 2, 59-62 (1957), [in Russian]
[87] Zinner, Paul E., Communist Strategy and Tactics in Czechoslovakia, 1918-1948 (1963), Praeger: Praeger Boulder, CO, pp. 64-65, 128
This reference list is based on information provided by the publisher or from digital mathematics libraries. Its items are heuristically matched to zbMATH identifiers and may contain data conversion errors. In some cases that data have been complemented/enhanced by data from zbMATH Open. This attempts to reflect the references listed in the original paper as accurately as possible without claiming completeness or a perfect matching.